Renters Insurance: What You're Actually Paying For
Most landlords require renters insurance. Some tenants buy the cheapest policy and forget about it. Here's the problem: cheap policies often don't cover the things that actually happen — water damage, theft, or your landlord blaming you for something that was already broken. We compared the major providers so you can pick the one that actually protects you.
Disclosure: Some links on this page may be affiliate links in the future. If we earn a commission, it will be clearly marked and will not affect our ratings. We rank by value to renters, not by who pays us. Companies with partnerships will be labeled “DepositHawk Partner.”
| Provider | Monthly Cost | Personal Property | Liability | Deductible | Claims Experience | Best For | Rating | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lemonade | $5–25 | $10K–100K | $100K | $250–500 | Fast — AI-processed, most paid in minutes. NAIC complaint ratio: 0.56 (below avg = good) | Tech-savvy renters, fast claims | 4.5/5 | Get a Quote |
| State Farm | $15–30 | $15K–100K | $100K–300K | $500–1,000 | Established — traditional claims process. NAIC complaint ratio: 0.89 (average). Agent-assisted. | Bundling with auto insurance | 4.3/5 | Get a Quote |
| Allstate | $15–35 | $15K–100K | $100K–300K | $500–1,000 | Mixed — some delays reported on larger claims. NAIC complaint ratio: 1.23 (above avg). App + agent. | Customizable coverage | 4.0/5 | Get a Quote |
| USAA | $10–20 | $15K–100K | $100K–300K | $250–500 | Excellent — consistently top-rated for claims satisfaction. NAIC complaint ratio: 0.31 (very low). Members only. | Military families (members only) | 4.8/5 | Get a Quote |
| Progressive | $10–25 | $10K–100K | $100K | $500 | Adequate — standard process. NAIC complaint ratio: 1.05 (slightly above avg). Online + phone. | Budget-conscious | 3.8/5 | Get a Quote |
| Travelers | $15–30 | $15K–100K | $100K–300K | $500–1,000 | Solid — good for complex claims. NAIC complaint ratio: 0.78 (below avg). Agent-assisted. | Broad coverage | 4.1/5 | Get a Quote |
| Toggle (Farmers) | $5–20 | $5K–50K | $100K | $250 | Basic — limited claims support for low-cost plans. NAIC complaint ratio: 1.15 (above avg). App only. | Bare minimum required by lease | 3.5/5 | Get a Quote |
What renters insurance actually covers
Theft, fire, and water damage to your stuff. Your laptop, furniture, clothes. If someone breaks in or a pipe bursts, this is what pays.
Someone gets hurt in your apartment and sues you. A guest slips, a dog bite, a fire you accidentally started. Liability pays for legal costs and damages.
If your apartment becomes uninhabitable — say, from a fire — loss of use pays for hotel stays and extra living costs while repairs happen.
Pays small medical bills for guests injured in your unit, regardless of fault. Usually $1K–5K. Keeps minor incidents from turning into lawsuits.
What it doesn't cover
- Floods — that's a separate federal flood insurance policy
- Earthquakes — also a separate policy in most states
- Your roommate's stuff — they need their own policy
- Your car — that's what auto insurance is for
- Bedbugs, roaches, and other pests — almost always excluded
- Intentional damage you cause yourself
How much coverage do you need?
The rule of thumb: add up what it would cost to replace everything you own tomorrow. Not what you paid — what it would cost to buy it again, new. Most people underestimate this by 40–60%. A laptop, TV, clothes, furniture, and kitchen gear adds up faster than you think. If you own anything worth more than $1,000, pick a coverage limit above $25K.
Does renters insurance help with deposit disputes?
Not directly. Renters insurance covers your stuff — it doesn't cover your deposit. But the two are related in a practical way: documenting your apartment's condition from move-in protects you for both insurance claims and deposit disputes. If your landlord claims you damaged something, photos and timestamped records are the same evidence that wins both fights. DepositHawk handles that documentation for $3/mo.
Protecting your stuff is half the equation. Protecting your deposit is the other half.
Protect My Deposit — $3/moCommon questions
Is renters insurance required?
Most landlords require it, but state law doesn't in any US state. If your lease says you need it, you need it.
How much does renters insurance cost?
$10-25/mo for most renters. The cheapest policies start at $5/mo but may not cover enough.
Can my landlord make me get renters insurance?
Yes, if it's in your lease. And honestly, at $10-15/mo, it's worth having even if they don't require it.
More resources
DepositHawk is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. Information and documents are for informational purposes only. No attorney-client relationship is created. Consult a licensed attorney for advice specific to your situation.