Rental Fees in New York
Your landlord's lease has 14 line items that weren't in the listing. Here's which ones New York law lets you push back on.
New York regulates 5 categories of rental fees, including application fee, security deposit, broker fee, and more.
New York requires landlords to disclose all mandatory fees before lease signing. Undisclosed fees may be unenforceable.
•Common Charges
Fees Your New York Landlord Can Charge
These fees show up on leases across New York. Some are standard operating costs passed to tenants. Others are profit centers dressed up as necessities. The “Negotiable” column tells you which ones other tenants have successfully pushed back on.
| Fee | Typical Range | Negotiable? |
|---|---|---|
| Valet Trash | $20–$45/mo | Rarely |
| Amenity Fee | $25–$75/mo | Often yes |
| Pest Control Fee | $5–$15/mo | Rarely |
| Technology/Internet Package | $30–$75/mo | Often yes |
| Pet Rent | $25–$75/mo | Often yes |
| Parking Fee | $50–$200/mo | Often yes |
| Administrative Fee | $50–$300 one-time | Often yes |
| Utility Billing Fee (RUBS) | $20–$60/mo | Rarely |
| Common Area Maintenance | $10–$30/mo | Rarely |
| Renters Insurance Requirement | $15–$30/mo | Rarely |
•Regulated Fees
Fees That Are Regulated in New York
New York law puts limits on these fees. If your landlord charged you more than the cap — or failed to follow the rules below — you have a statutory basis to dispute.
| Fee Type | Cap | Rule | Statute |
|---|---|---|---|
| Application fee | $20 | Application fees capped at $20 per applicant under the Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019. | N.Y. Real Prop. Law § 238-a |
| Security deposit | See rule | Security deposit capped at one month rent. No last-month-rent collection allowed. | N.Y. Gen. Oblig. Law § 7-108 |
| Broker fee | See rule | NYC broker fees were temporarily shifted to landlords under 2025 city legislation (FARE Act), though litigation is ongoing. | NYC Admin. Code § 26-702 (FARE Act) |
| Late fee | $50 | Late fees capped at $50 or 5% of monthly rent, whichever is less. Cannot be charged until rent is 5 days late. | N.Y. Real Prop. Law § 238-a(2) |
| Move-in/move-out fee | See rule | Non-refundable move-in fees are prohibited. Any move-in payment beyond first month rent and one month security deposit is illegal. | N.Y. Gen. Oblig. Law § 7-108 |
Application fees capped at $20 per applicant under the Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019. (New York)
Security deposit capped at one month rent. No last-month-rent collection allowed. (New York)
NYC broker fees were temporarily shifted to landlords under 2025 city legislation (FARE Act), though litigation is ongoing. (New York)
Late fees capped at $50 or 5% of monthly rent, whichever is less. Cannot be charged until rent is 5 days late. (New York)
Non-refundable move-in fees are prohibited. Any move-in payment beyond first month rent and one month security deposit is illegal. (New York)
•Recent Changes
Recent Legislation
NYC FARE Act (2025) — shifts broker fees to landlords in NYC
NYC FARE Act (2025) — shifts broker fees to landlords in NYC
•Dispute Process
How to Dispute a Fee in New York
File in New York Small Claims Court (up to $5,000 in NYC, $10,000 in town/village courts). Tenants can also file complaints with the NY Attorney General or NYC Dept. of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD). Overcharge claims can be filed with DHCR for rent-stabilized tenants.
- Pull your lease. Find the exact clause authorizing the fee. If it is not in the lease, that is your first argument.
- Write your landlord. Send a written dispute (email is fine) citing the specific fee amount, why you believe it is improper, and what remedy you want. Keep it factual.
- File if ignored. If your landlord does not respond within 14 days, file in small claims court in the county where the rental property is located. Bring your lease, payment records, and any written communications.
•Transparency
Is Your Landlord Required to Disclose Fees?
Yes. New York law requires landlords to disclose all mandatory fees before you sign the lease. This means every recurring charge — valet trash, amenity fees, pest control, technology packages — must be listed and explained upfront.
If a fee appears on your first statement that was not disclosed before signing, you have grounds to challenge it. Document the discrepancy in writing and reference the applicable statute when you dispute.
●Frequently Asked Questions
Frequently Asked Questions
Can my New York landlord charge a valet trash fee?
It depends. New York regulates certain rental fees. Check the statute for your specific fee type. If the fee was not disclosed before you signed the lease — which is required by law in New York — you may have grounds to dispute it.
Are amenity fees legal in New York?
Amenity fees are not outright banned in most states, including New York. But if your landlord charges you for amenities you cannot access or never use — a pool fee when the pool is closed, a gym fee when the gym is under renovation — that fee may be disputable. New York requires landlords to disclose all mandatory fees before lease signing.
How do I dispute a rental fee in New York?
File in New York Small Claims Court (up to $5,000 in NYC, $10,000 in town/village courts). Tenants can also file complaints with the NY Attorney General or NYC Dept. of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD). Overcharge claims can be filed with DHCR for rent-stabilized tenants.
Does New York require landlords to disclose all fees upfront?
Yes. New York law requires landlords to disclose all mandatory fees before you sign the lease. Fees added after the fact or buried in addenda may be unenforceable.
Can I negotiate rental fees in New York?
Some fees are negotiable — amenity fees, pet rent, and parking fees are commonly reduced or waived during lease negotiation. Others like valet trash and utility billing (RUBS) are typically non-negotiable because the landlord has a contract with a third-party vendor. Always ask. The worst they can say is no.
12 tools to protect your money. $3/mo →
DepositHawk is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. Information and documents are for informational purposes only. No attorney-client relationship is created. Consult a licensed attorney for advice specific to your situation.